Thats the only reason, its just gooey. All of this info was compiled from various butchers and online sources. Drain the marinade and add the pork to a 5-quart slow cooker. I am planning a large event and want to make sure I have enough. . My preference is Pork Shoulder or Boneless Pork Rib meat! This recipe has always been a hit, especially in our family. Here is the old recipe: Thank you so much for taking the time to share this recipe its fabulous I live down the street from the Cafe Rio and I eat there all the time. You can find my full directions on how to make it here. I used the green can of El Pato (jalepeno salsa). Cook the shredded pork in the crockpot with the sauce for 2 hours on low. The result was excellent! Si. Im eating it right now for the third day in a row, still in awe at how delicious it is. As far as pork butt/shoulder goes, if its not shred-able, just keep cooking. Every time I eat it, its like a warm homey feeling comes over me. Kamie, I had my doubts because the ingredients seem so random, but we love this recipe and have done it with and without marinade several times. Lets treat others how wed like to be treated . You could try to add more brown sugar to compensate if you absolutely cannot find or use a regular soda. And the other 50% of the judges liked my moms recipe! I followed the recipe to a T, also making the ABK homemade menudo dry rub and the ABK Homemade Enchilada Sauce for the simmering meat. Sprinkle the garlic salt and salt and pepper over the meat and cook on high for 6 hours. Interesting fact- the name Boston butt originates from 18th century New England when pork was packed in barrels (which were also known as butts) to store and ship meat. We love this pork! Maybe they will give me a hint. Ive read those books and enjoyed them except for the ending of the Giver. You can't go wrong! The pork is marinated and slow-cooked to perfection in some surprising ingredients! Cut pork loin into three to four large chunks and add to crockpot. I made it in the crock pot on high with a 5 lb pork shoulder. Hi Allison, if youre using a 4 lb roast, I would set the pressure time for 70-80 minutes. Let us know how it turns out! Tips and Secrets for perfect Cafe Rio Sweet Pork! Thank you! This is my go to sweet pork recipe. I am one of those people that wont print out a recipe until it meets the mark. If you are in a hurry, skip this step and omit the oil in the pot. I have always marinated my pork the night before or for at least a couple hours, but if you forget or just dont have time go ahead and cook it without marinading it. Si. This post may contain affiliate links. ? A few I use, a few I do not. But both have a good side, for example the protein and iron is awesome in beef. We moved from Utah to Mississippi and its nowhere around! In a small bowl, mix together the garlic powder, chili powder, cumin, smoked paprika, salt, pepper, onion powder, and oregano. Some say Dr. Pepper. Si. The pork cooks for a long time in the slow cooker which makes the meat tender and easy to shred. Your email address will not be published. If your slow cooker is big enough you should be ok with the same time. I made this last night for my family and we had Missionaries over and everybody loved it- the leftovers are amazing too! Added some lettuce, corn salsa, pico, and cotija cheese and it was so, so good! I planned and prepped, started the process and allotted for 8 hrs, as top of recipe states but did not realize until it was too late there was additional 2 hours. Thank you, Si! Place pork shoulder or butt in a slow cooker and pour 1 cup each of Dr. Pepper and water over the meat. -Pork is marinated in Coke, full strength, not Diet Coke. I usually do not have to increase the cook time much for a larger roast, but I would allow for an extra hour to be safe! Si. You made my day Rebecca! In your tips it says to simmer pork with cut up yellow onions (later you suggest caramelizing the onions prior), serrano peppers and carrots and then discard the peppers and carrots. Place the lid on the top of the pot (make sure the sealing ring is in place inside of the lid) and lock into sealing position. This recipe looks delicious! Toss into your preferred salad or burrito! This pork look so saucy and delicious! If Im using 2.5 lbs of pork instead of 4 like this recipe calls for, do I still do the full two cups of water and 50 minutes pressure cooked time? Im so glad youre trying this recipe, I know youll love it! It goes perfectly in burritos, tacos, salads and so much more. Only thing I think we were missing was a little heat, will use hot chiles and enchilada sauce next time. It is so yummy! Si. Total time: 410 minutes Cook time: 400 minutes Prep time: 10 minutes Yields: 12 servings Cuisine: Mexican Number of ingredients: 7 Ingredients: 3 lbs. I hope this helps! Sorry Christine, but thanks for trying it. That extra 1 to 2 hours after shredding the pork and pouring in the remaining ingredients is just meant to heat it all up together. Not quite the same as Cafe Rio, but Ill definitely make it again! Subscribe to our e-mail newsletter to receive updates. Si. A Bountiful Kitchen Cookbook, filled with recipes, photos, stories, and special notes from me, is now available for purchase! I will update that ASAP, thank you for letting me know. So delicious! Thats because it tastes so similar to the original. Discard the liquid from the slow cooker. I have not tried this recipe using chicken, but if I were to try it, I would use the same amount of chicken as pork (3 lbs) but cook it for about 6 hours. The pork slow cooks all day, and then at dinnertime, you have an amazing dish to serve to your family. IM planning on tripling it for a birthday PARTy. Hi Deb, Im sorry to hear that. $2.49 is about what I paid 10 minutes ago. Si. Spread some garlic salt, salt, and pepper around. Your pork is incredible. Do I have to thaw my meat? Can you please post or send me the old recipe? I hope you all enjoy. [ Note to judges: this was recipe 2 for all of you that preferred this one] *Recipe here [amd-zlrecipe-recipe:10] The aromatics totally make a difference, but you throw them out after its done cooking. I make everything ahead and then we simply chop up lettuce and tomatoes and grill fresh tortillas for a homemade Cafe Rio style feast! Hi Ginger, thats so sweet of you to help out your sister! I made this yesterday and it was delicious and so much better than having to remember to thaw the pork a day in advance and then put it in the crock pot first thing in the morning. Finally got around to making this in the crockpot yesterday. Help!!! Im so excited to make this. Thanks! I did it for 8 hours and it was falling apart YUM! Sweet pork is my favorite meat at Cafe Rio. If you buy lean cuts of pork, your Instant Pot Cafe Rio Sweet Pork will not taste like Cafe Rios Pork. I couldnt find the old elpaso sauce packets so I ended up using a 10oz can of red enchilada sauce and adding an entire small head of crushed garlic to it. If the chicken is frozen cook for 13 minutes and then check it should be easy to shred. This looks so good! Remove all liquid from the slow cooker. The extra two hours gives the shredded meat a chance to soak up more of the marinade. Cafe Rio pork is my fav! 4 Ways to Make Dr. Pepper - wikiHow . I followed the recipe to a T with a 5 lb boneless butt roast and my meat turned out a gelatinous mess swimming in sauce. We have used it and it was pretty good but we are working on a new recipe since we cant find that cooking sauce anymore. . Cafe Rio Sweet Pork {Copycat} Recipe [+ Video]. Is the additional 2 hours of cooking (step 4) necessary after the meat has already cooked 8 hours? Thanks. xo I have a 7lb pork butt and I dont want to chance it in my instant pot. Sorry about the half eaten salad in this next pictureit was SO good that I forgot to take a picture before I ate most of it! A 4 oz. Remove from the oven and allow to rest for 1-2 hours. This recipe is the most spot on i have ever found. I need to feed 100 hungry lacrosse players after practice next Thursday and want to have enough! Cafe Rio sweet pork can be served on a bed of white rice with toppings such as sliced jalapeno, diced tomatoes, and fresh cilantro. xo, Place the seasoned pork roast into the slow cooker. (Roast can be omitted.) Its is good any way, shape or form! Everyone at my family gathering loved it. Filed under: Dinner, Family Reunion Food, Mexican, Pork, Slow Cooker and Instant Pot, Videos. -Only use pork butt or shoulder. I made this for Sunday dinner and it was huge hit! Ive made this recipe now as its written, and with keto substitutes, and they were both divine!! Combine a can and a half of Coke with about a quarter cup of brown sugar. EVER. My slow cooked method posted previously recommends marinating, but this recipe does not. 2- Cut pork roast into quarters and add to the Instant Pot. i made this yesterday! Its THAT good! I have made this recipe all the same prep steps and ingredients with a few tweaks to use an instant pot : 3 lbs of pork tenderloin cut into chunks for 55 minutes on manual (with the grate that lifts the meat mostly off the bottom of the pot. ! Jared, We love, love, love this recipe! This is by far the best sweet pork recipe! I would totally make this again. Theyre smoked jalapeos, but the adobo sauce they come canned in is the magical part. And then, when they picked their favorite, they got to make an entire sweet pork salad (or burrito). So I thought it was a quick dinner. When we go to Cafe Rio, I pretty much always get the salad to split (this is quite rare as the hubs DOES NOT split anything. xo I dont need to spend 10 bucks for one at Cafe Rio ever again when I can make it so easily at home! I bought a 9lb pork shoulder. Hi Cristi, Put shredded pork and sauce in crockpot and cook on low for 2 hours. Thanks for this amazing recipe! Is there anyway to use store bought pulled pork to speed up the recipe? Rub with garlic salt and pour 2 cups of coke and cook on low for 7-8 hours or high for 5-6. I have another question, will cooking the pork shoulder in a crock pot break down the fat enough that it will shred ok? Have you found a good replacement for The Old El Paso cooking sauce packet which is no longer available? Made some mistakes about draining the juices but it was pretty fool proof turns out. Cafe Rio {Copycat} Creamy Tomatillo Cilantro Ranch Dressing [+ Video], Cilantro Lime Rice Cafe Rio {Copycat} [+ Video], Crock Pot Cafe Rio {Copycat} Chicken [+ Video], Smothered Cafe Rio {Copycat} Chicken Burrito.